A fair question from any Shopify founder is “what does a retention agency cost?” The useful answer is a range, plus a clear list of what you should get for it. Price without scope is how brands end up with cheap campaign execution and no one accountable for revenue.
Here is how pricing usually works, what should be included, and what Magic Potion Marketing charges.
What is the typical price range?
For a growing ecommerce brand — most of our clients sit in the $1M–$20M+ range, with traffic and an existing list — specialist retention work usually comes in two parts:
- A one-time rebuild or audit-and-build project, to put the system in place.
- A monthly retainer, to run, test, and grow that system.
At Magic Potion Marketing:
- Retention system rebuild: $4,500–$7,500 one time.
- Ongoing retention program: $4,500–$8,000 per month.
- Larger or more complex brands are quoted individually.
Those are senior-team prices. You will find retainers below this, sometimes well below. You will also find enterprise quotes well above it. The question is not whether a number is “high.” It is whether the fee buys strategy, architecture, testing, and results — or only sends.
What should a rebuild include?
A rebuild is not a teardown of every template for its own sake. It is a project to make the lifecycle match the brand you are now, not the brand that set up Klaviyo two years ago.
You should get:
- An audit of flows, campaigns, list health, deliverability, and reporting.
- A customer-journey map and a recommended system: welcome, browse and cart, post-purchase, replenishment if needed, win-back, VIP, and the role of SMS.
- Rebuilt or newly built core flows, with segmentation and exclusion rules that match how you sell.
- A testing plan and a reporting model tied to revenue, AOV, and repeat behavior — not opens alone.
- A clear handoff into ongoing work, or into your in-house team, so the system does not sit still after the project.
Our rebuild range of $4,500–$7,500 covers that work for most brands in our sweet spot. If the account is unusually complex — multiple storefronts, a heavy catalog, subscriptions layered on one-time products, or a messy data setup — we quote it separately instead of squeezing it into a band that will not fit.
What should a monthly retainer include?
Once the system exists, someone has to run it. A real ongoing retention program should include:
- Campaign strategy and execution on an agreed cadence.
- Flow monitoring and optimization, not “set and forget.”
- List-growth recommendations (capture, consent, and welcome), without confusing that with a full paid-acquisition brief.
- Structured A/B testing with a written backlog and documented winners.
- SMS used with a defined job, not as a carbon copy of email.
- A monthly report that leads with revenue, flow versus campaign contribution, and what you will test next.
Our retainer range of $4,500–$8,000 per month is for that operating rhythm, done by senior people. Where you sit in the range depends on send volume, catalog complexity, SMS scope, and how much of the creative and production work we own.
If a retainer is mostly “we will send four campaigns,” you are buying a production slot. Ask what happens when flows break, when AOV stalls, or when you need a point of view on the calendar.
How does this compare with hiring in-house?
A capable in-house lifecycle hire often costs $75,000–$90,000+ fully loaded once you add benefits, tools, recruiting, and management — and that is for one person. Senior operators cost more. A junior hire costs less on paper and usually needs a playbook and close oversight.
A specialist retainer in the $4,500–$8,000 monthly range is often less than that seat, and you get a team that already knows how to build the system. That is why many brands in the $1M–$20M+ range start with an agency, then hire later into a program that already works. We compare the two paths in retention agency vs. in-house hire.
Why do some agencies charge much less — or much more?
Below the range usually means one of three things: a junior pod, a narrow scope (campaigns only, or a flow build with no strategy), or a loss-leader to get in the account. None of those is automatically bad, but they are not the same product as a senior team that owns results.
Above the range can be fair for large or complex brands, heavier creative production, or a team embedded almost full time. It can also be a generalist agency pricing, with retention as one slice of a larger retainer. Ask who does the work and how much of the fee is senior time.
Beware of two other patterns: very low setup fees that hide a long retainer, and “unlimited campaigns” that push volume instead of revenue.
What should you ask before you sign?
- Who designs the architecture, and who builds the emails? Will you meet the people doing the work?
- What is included in the monthly fee, and what is billed as a project?
- How do you measure success? If the answer leads with opens, keep asking.
- What does the first 30, 60, and 90 days look like?
- How do you handle SMS, deliverability, and list hygiene?
- If we hire in-house later, how do you hand off?
A Klaviyo partner badge is a useful signal of platform familiarity. It is not a substitute for those answers. We are a Klaviyo partner, and we still own the judgment and the outcome. Tools help. They do not run the program.
What do you get for the money, in business terms?
You are buying a more predictable owned-channel revenue stream: a list that is treated like an asset, flows that keep earning between campaigns, and a testing rhythm so the program does not freeze. In work we can cite, that has included a 38% lift in average order value for a skincare brand, a 74% lift in SMS revenue, and 32% revenue growth across ecommerce and DTC brands.
Those numbers are not a promise about your account. They are proof that the work, when it is owned properly, shows up in commercial results.
FAQ
Is the rebuild required, or can we go straight to a retainer?
If the system is already sound, you can start on a retainer. If flows are outdated, segmentation is thin, and reporting is open-rate heavy, a rebuild first is faster and cleaner. We will tell you which we think it is after a review.
Are there long contracts?
Ask any agency this directly, including us, and get the term, notice period, and what happens to assets on exit in writing. You should own your Klaviyo account, your lists, and the work product in the account.
Do prices include design, copy, and SMS?
In our ongoing program, strategy, execution, testing, and reporting are in the monthly range; exact creative and SMS scope is set in the proposal so you are not surprised. If another agency’s quote does not say, assume it is not included.
What if we are larger than the $20M+ end of your usual range?
We still work with larger brands when the fit is strong. Those engagements are quoted individually, because the system, the stake, and the operating rhythm are different.
Book a retention review
If you want a clear recommendation — rebuild, retainer, or hire — we will review your flows, campaigns, and list health and tell you what the work should cost and include.
No responses yet